Scrapped Princess – when light novels weren’t so mainstream

Alternative title Haiki Oujo
Studio Bones
Genres Action, Drama, Sci-fi, Slice of Life
Source Light novels
Episodes 24
Season Spring 2003
Director Souichi Masui
Music Masumi Itou
.

    What is your reaction when you hear that a particular anime is adapted from a light novel? Probably less enthusiastic than it would be if the source material was manga or, better still, it would be an original work. And today I chose to cover precisely an adaptation of a light novel series. But don’t shove it off as something generic – there’re three particular things I want you to remember – “Bones”, “2003” and “complete”. “Bones” is self-explanatory, as “2003” is since at that time light novels weren’t as common as they are now and naturally nowadays overused tropes were far less likely to appear. “Complete” should also sound good since this anime isn’t a usual ad for the source material – it follows the whole story, from start to the very end. So yeah, dear readers – Scrapped Princess.

    Before we get on with it, I think some clarification is necessary. Generally if you see some promotional art or a DVD cover with people clothed in supposedly fantasy anime attire, it doesn’t necessarily mean that the show will be Pure Illusion…sorry, I mean pure fantasy. Even if some dudes are wielding axes or swords. I say this because that’s precisely what happened to me with Scrapped Princess – I was mentally unprepared to encounter sci-fi in the show, but first things first.

     As the story starts, we find the titular princess Pacifica on a run together with her foster-siblings Shannon and Raquel. The reason behind all this is that it has been prophesied that once Pacifica turns 16, she’ll become “a poison that will destroy the world”. Naturally, nobody wants that, especially the church (yep, again an evil church trope). The church is pretty influential, and not least because it’s associated with some powerful and almost angelic beings named Peacemakers. Imagine then the situation of Pacifica, to whom it may seem that the only two in the whole world who don’t want to kill her are her siblings. Especially since it’s more than clear that Pacifica seems to be the least likely person to cause world destruction.

.     Where Scrapped Princess really excels is the characters, or, to be more precise, interactions between them. In the center of everything is of course our heroine Pacifica (as if you couldn’t guess from her colorful clothes). At first she seemed like a usual bratty and spoilt ojou-sama character who can’t stand traveling in a cart and doing anything by herself. It turns out (as expected) that Pacifica is able to grow a spine and act like a real princess (in a good sense). As the plot progressed, Pacifica didn’t get many opportunities to be relaxed and comfortable, and she grew accustomed to her situation quite quickly. Far more important than that is, as her name suggests, Pacifica’s desire to live in peace without causing trouble to anyone. That is made especially clear when Pacifica’s close friends and family are concerned – it’s even hard to believe that the same once whiny girl could offer her hand (literally, not figuratively) in order to find her siblings when they became separated at one point. Pacifica’s compassion for others makes it particularly hard for her to come into terms with the prophecy that she will likely be the end of all the people. Isn’t it quite a scary world when you just want to live and pretty much everybody else wants you dead? Still it’s not enough to break Pacifica – in every situation she eventually is able to find some inner strength and will to proceed, and that’s a trait that makes her worthy to be called a princess.

    Pacifica’s siblings Shannon and Raquel often just seem to be here and we rarely get a glimpse of their actual thoughts and opinions. They are primarily important to Pacifica as her guardians, almost parental figures, who look after her, give her strength and provide comfort. Of course I would’ve liked to see more of them, but even without any plot changes both Shannon and Raquel are integral to the story. Of all the other characters the biggest impression was made by Leo. Aspiring to become a knight but often struggling (for comedic purposes), he becomes enchanted with Pacifica and because of that sticks with the group. When he learns who Pacifica actually is, Leo is posed with a dilemma – on one hand he should behave as a good citizen and chop Pacifica’s head off, but he simply can’t do that after seeing what kind of innocent girl Pacifica is. I wouldn’t say this theme of an impossible choice (with one’s possible future career at stake) and the meaning of justice gets enough development but it’s a great way of making the world more morally grey.

     Fun fact – for some reason many characters are named after specific guns. You may not even notice that at first, but after some time weird naming choices of gods Mauser and Browning as well as characters like Winia Chester among others become more apparent. I’ve no idea why the names were chosen like that. It almost makes as little sense as everyone named after eggs and egg-dishes in Mardock Scramble. Yep, “scramble” also counts.

     After the initial succession of great episodes Scrapped Princess seemed to have run out of gas, but at that point everything became more complicated when some sci-fi elements were introduced. It wasn’t totally unexpected – some skyscraper ruins were already seen quite early. Also, these elements never become the focus of the story – you can never forget that everything that happens, does so in a primarily medieval setting. Inevitably coexistence of swords and lasers called for some explanation, and naturally we got that, only in a form of several exposition-heavy and rather boring episodes.

     Then another change (for the better) occurred when Pacifica, her siblings, Leo and a few other important characters (scattered after their initial introduction) inadvertently and independently came to the capital city. The characters are the main force behind the likability of the show so more interactions between beloved dudes were nothing more I could’ve asked. The only questionable aspect of this mini-arc was that an amnesia plotline was introduced. I wouldn’t say it was absolutely uncalled for, and it did provide some great moments but in the grand scheme of things the amnesia disappeared as suddenly as it came, and with a puzzling side effect of erasing memories formed during the amnesia period. I’ve no idea why the story played out that way – I can only see a great opportunity for further development lost without any reason.

     Many of my previous criticisms may be dismissed simply as preferences, but there’re some bigger issues. Until the story starts moving at full speed near the final third, temporary villains weren’t particularly impressive – they either lacked believable (or just known) motivations or were defeated way too quickly to have any lasting impact. Later on, sometimes I found it hard to believe that the villains really wanted to achieve their goals since communication problems or simply avoidance of seemingly logical actions happened quite often. Another problem became apparent when the sci-fi became more prominent – it was told that people who chose to help Pacifica were at least strongly encouraged to do so by some specific genes they possessed. That a bit undermined their resolve to swim against the stream and help Pacifica as they were kind of preprogrammed to do so and behaved not entirely due to their free will. Yet the finale posed the biggest head-scratching moment – some characters were confirmed to be dead and then magically revived without any explanation apparently for none other reason  than that they just deserved a happy ending.

.
Pacifica's cooking is excellent, right?

    Talking about the visuals, the most obvious attribute making the show look way older than it deserves is the aspect ratio 4:3. Yeah, Bones didn’t think that out enough. Still, it’s Bones, and even if actual fighting scenes aren’t a frequent sight, everything is done adequately, especially considering the time period it aired. More impressive than action scenes are some (sadly rare) moments of character animation that usually perfectly conveyd the precise emotion that was needed. Some tiny scene of Pacifica rolling her eyes or a brief cut of a hand gesture could make me replay it half a dozen times to fully appreciate the craft. Character animation was especially well used for comedic purposes, and, frankly, pretty much all the comedy in Scrapped Princess was to my liking, and that is a rare case. Returning to the visuals, character designs need to be mentioned. You can argue that they are very generic and usual for their time period but I can’t completely agree with that. Especially Pacifica looks unique with her one-of-the-kind hairstyle and colorful clothes that instantly make her the center of attention. Sure, women’s physique may seem a bit odd at times, but oh well.

 Excerpt from the OST: Suin Nazo no Syoujo by Masumi Itou

 

     The OST does its job ok. Its composer Masumi Itou you should probably know for her vocal works. Her usual style is quite recognizable – apart from singing the ED of this show, she also did the same for Azumanga Daioh, and more recently heavily contributed to the ED of Flip Flappers (I still can’t get that tune out of my head). The soundtrack of Scrapped Princess however is a bit different. I always appreciate some orchestral music, and it generally suits these high fantasy/sci-fi tales. I can’t deny that the soundtrack is able to enhance calm moments and battle scenes, but to me it wasn’t very impressive on its own. As if it lacks more pronounced themes and some cohesion between the instruments. Speaking about the themes, there’s one that sounds exactly like a rip-off from Howard Shore’s Isengard theme from The Lord of the Rings. As much as the soundtrack is able to do its job well, I’m afraid I’d rather listen to anything by, say, Youko Kanno anytime.

.
Excerpt from the OST: Coulisse to Shannon no Tatakai by Kenji Kondou

     You might look at Scrapped Princess and see many various tropes like some characters looking like they rather belong to a JRPG, or the fact that Winia is simply an Ayanami-clone, looks included. You might also laugh at some weird narrative choices (a convenient window between separate cells in a dungeon? Why on earth would you do that?). Still, in the end it’s the characters that matter, and there the show has me fully satisfied – even the villains receive some moments of humanization, and that’s only the bottom line. Instances when Pacifica is put in a hard situation were particularly strong. That heartfelt momentary despair and ultimately resolve to set things straight even if there is no obvious and easy solution will probably remain in my memories for a long time as the best thing I can recall about Scrapped Princess, and that’s not even taking into account the main theme – a conflict between what a person is perceived as and what he really is – being executed very well.

    I believe, this anime is

 1

Decent

     Anyone who is tired of all this isekai stuff but still enjoys adventure shows should at least try this one. As well as anyone who loves well-crafted characters but isn’t afraid of some tropes or for the most part rather unimpressive animation.

     Have you seen Scrapped Princess? If yes, what are your thoughts about it? Have you encountered any other anime whose characters carried the show whereas other aspects weren’t that impressive?

Advertisements
Leave a comment

17 Comments

  1. I loved reading your thoughts on this (though the OST didn’t work for me…probably just my bad WiFi). Seems like a highly pleasant show to watch!

    Liked by 2 people

    Reply
  2. I’m glad other people are getting around to reviewing this show too. I wouldn’t call it spectacular, but it is worth a watch.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
    • There’s a surprisingly huge variety of older shows that just don’t seem to exist in the conversation of the community so every voice bringing it to the light is important. I think even with all the flaws Scrapped Princess would be at least equal to the majority of currently airing anime.

      Like

      Reply
  3. This one has been on my watch list for a long time but I still haven’t actually got to it. I’ve seen a number of reviews on it recently and I must admit, I’m probably going to try to see it later this year because it does look interesting. Thanks for sharing.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
    • We all know the endless and hardly escapable hell of watch lists. Hope Scrapped Princess will be able to break out of yours. Already waiting for your thoughts after watching it then!
      Thanks for stopping by!

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply
  4. Man I just finished talking about this show with my brother today! I loved the show, but the ending honestly ruined it for me and left a sour taste in my mouth ever since I watched it years ago. I loved the characters, the world building, and all the plot points in spite of some of the ridiculous situations the crew got themselves in at times but that ending….ugh, it was so bad. The one time an ending ruined an otherwise good show for me.

    I completely agree with all your thoughts about the show! It’s a great story, in spite of all the tropes involved.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
    • Well, coincidences do happen (even if we usually don’t like them in stories) and I’m grateful that it led you here.

      As I think about the show now, somehow my mind tries to forget the ending and to remember only the best parts. But yeah, Scrapped Princess sadly deserves a spot in Top 10 list of worst endings.

      Like

      Reply
  5. Scrapped princess was one of the first anime I saw in Japanese when I was a kid, the animation quality (along with Saint Seiya Hades part 1) is what made me an anime fan today. I quite enjoyed the anime. It looks like you did not like the ending, but to me it was not a bad one, I would say it had some holes (and the ship did not officially sailed too ^^) but it was an happy end, especially after all they went through. And Pacifica is just one of the best character ever !
    You said the anime adapted the LN from start to end, but since the LN had 13 volumes I suppose it skipped many things ? When I finish learning Kanjis, I will read the side stories as well.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
    • Actually I meant Raquel is one of the best character ^^ lol.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply
      • True. I probably like Pacifica more, but Raquel’s presence was very important. Actually, Raquel’s characterization might be another case of trimming to in the given time. Which again is very unfortunate. I would’ve happily watched Scrapped Princess if it was twice as long.

        Liked by 1 person

        Reply
    • I can easily see Scrapped Princess getting anyone into anime. It’s very engaging and thematically close to something a Westerner could create.
      Definitely the ending could’ve been far worse. If the idea of a possible resurrection was established before the fact of the resurrection itself, I think I would’ve liked it better. Now it seemed very unexpected and ungrounded. Still, once it was confirmed that everyone is alive and well, everything was wrapped pretty well. Though yeah, the ship didn’t sail.
      Actually, I get the feeling that the ending was one of the instances of material being cut down to fit in the given time. Also I think that everything concerning Chris’s buddies was toned down as well for the same reason. Still, the adaptation works great, and in the end that’s all that matters.
      Lucky you. I still have some very little hope that somebody will pick up the translation. The fact that the official translation was discontinued is very sad.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply
      • Yeah I agree, the resurrection was a bit out of nowhere. As for Raquel she indeed lacks a lot of development if we compare to her brother. Maybe in the LN she has more.

        Liked by 1 person

        Reply
  6. gebels

     /  April 15, 2019

    you read 13 volumes novel Scrapped princess? In anime addapt all volumes novels?

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
    • As a matter of fact, I didn’t. There’re only 3 volumes ever translated to English in the first place. My knowledge thus is very limited so I’d better not make any firm statements. The truth is that after 13 volumes of the novels (and the end of the anime series) 5 more volumes were released (containing side stories) so in that sense the anime doesn’t adapt absolutely everything.

      Like

      Reply
  1. In Case You Missed It – 100WordAnime

Share Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: